Preview: Make these classic bread machine dinner rolls with a bread maker. They are beginner-friendly and taster-approved. No bread machine? No worries! You can still mix the dough in a stand mixer or do it by hand. See the recipe notes for details. Updated 2/13/21.
Does anybody still clip recipes in this day of virtual newspapers/magazines, Pinterest, and gorgeous picture cookbooks?
I clipped this recipe out of our local newspaper back in the ’80s. Whether it was a disgruntled employee or the cafeteria cooks themselves at a nearby school district, I’m so glad they shared their famous recipe for these scratch dinner rolls.
Even though it wasn’t a bread machine recipe per se, the recipe adapted beautifully in my then-new bread machine. I was hooked.
A million and one batches later, I can honestly say this recipe has been “tested and approved.” Proceed with confidence.
This bread machine yeast roll recipe was published in the early days of this website. When readers complained after it disappeared for a while, I republished it along with a video.
In keeping with my habit of continually tweaking recipes, I applied the Tangzhong technique to this recipe a couple of years ago. Although I think it is even better, it’s slightly more complicated. You can see that recipe here: The Softest Ever Bread Machine Dinner Roll
Ingredients and substitutions
- FLOUR: Unbleached flour is my first choice for a very scientific reason. It’s what I keep in the flour canister on my countertop making it easy to grab.
I’ve tried bread flour, white whole-wheat flour, and bleached flour. They all make great rolls.
- MILK: Whole milk is best. The more fat in the milk, the better. If you have some other milk on hand, go ahead and use it.
If you aren’t using whole milk, you could substitute 1 tablespoon of heavy cream for 1 tablespoon of milk. The liquid should not total more than 1 cup.
- EGG: I use nothing but “large” eggs in all of my bread recipes. Make adjustments in the amount of liquid if you use a different size egg.
- SUGAR: The recipe calls for 3 tablespoons of sugar. I often add only 2 tablespoons depending on how tight my pants are feeling that day. Suit yourself.
- BUTTER: The original recipe specified shortening, aka Crisco. After a few years of that, I switched to butter and never looked back. If you happen to be out of butter, you can use shortening as a substitute.
- YEAST: Again, the original recipe called for active dry yeast. I quickly exchanged the idea of waiting 10-minutes while the yeast dissolved for instant or bread machine yeast that doesn’t need to be dissolved. As it turns out, active dry yeast no longer needs to be dissolved.
- SALT: Use table salt or sea salt. If you want to use Kosher salt, add about 1/4 teaspoon more. Salt is an important part of the whole package so please don’t leave it out.
How do you use a bread machine to make dinner rolls?
If you are a bread-maker newbie, be sure to read 6 Bread Machine Secrets You Need To Know . For now, here’s the quick answer.
Use the bread machine DOUGH cycle to mix up the dough, knead it, and let it rise. That means you will dump all the ingredients (except the butter) into your bread machine pan in the order listed in the recipe. Start the machine.
Check the dough a couple of times by lifting the lid to take a peek. Do this right after the machine starts in order to make sure the paddles are engaged properly. It’s also an excellent time to add the butter. (See recipe.)
Check the consistency of the dough 10-15 minutes into the dough cycle.
If your dough is too wet, add flour 1 tablespoon at a time. The dough should stick to the side, then pull away cleanly.
Conversely, if the dough is too dry, add 1 tablespoon of liquid at a time until the dough looks just right. See the video for another illustration of how your dough should look.
“The goal is for the dough to be shiny and elastic. It should stick to the side, then pull away cleanly.”
Once the dough cycle ends, remove the dough from the machine and shape into balls. Place the balls of dough into baking pans and cover while they rise again. Bake rolls in your conventional oven.
Tips for bread machine dinner rolls:
Weigh the flour.
Weighing is more accurate than using a measuring cup. Since I started measuring, I rarely need to add more flour or liquid to my bread dough.
If you don’t have scales, fluff up the flour with your scoop or spoon. Spoon flour into a measuring cup with a delicate hand. Level. Please don’t be a “scooper.” This practice inevitably leads to too much flour and heavy rolls.
Measure the liquid carefully.
The proportions of liquid to flour is important in bread making. If you add too much liquid, you will have to add extra flour. If you add too much flour, you will have to add more liquid.
This also applies to the egg. Using a size larger or smaller will change the proportions.
Add softened butter after you start the bread machine.
This is a little-known secret I stumbled upon a couple of years ago. Now I do it with almost all of my bread recipes. Add the butter after you have started mixing all the other ingredients together.
After your machine has been running for about 1 minute, open the lid. Add the softened butter (important that it is neither melted nor hard) a tablespoon at a time to the dough.
The other ingredients get a chance to dissolve and mix together before the fat coats everything.
If you don’t do this or forget, no problem. Dumping everything in at once will still result in extraordinary dinner rolls.
Use a silicone baking sheet as your “floured surface.”
Silicone mats are the best platform for rolling out dough. Why? Because the mat is easy to wash. Throw it into the dishwasher.
Also, it doesn’t take as much flour to keep the dough from sticking. Try it and you’ll see what I mean.
Speaking of flour, if the dough is too sticky for you to manage, add flour to your hands and more to the surface. Try coating your hands with a little butter when shaping the balls to prevent sticking.
Use colored pans to get a nice crust on the bottom of your rolls.
My pans of choice are the gold-colored pans. After that, I would choose a pan with a dark non-stick surface. The heavier the pan, the better.
Lightweight aluminum pans or disposable foil pans are slow to brown. If it is your only choice, place the rolls onto the lower rack of your oven.
Check for doneness with a thermometer.
Some of you may be thinking, “I never saw my grandma use a thermometer.” I didn’t either. Experience can take the place of a thermometer.
But if you’re a beginner or you like to try new recipes, a thermometer can save you a lot of disappointment. It doesn’t have to be a fancy one. A quick-read thermometer with a long and skinny probe (paid link) works best.
When using a thermometer, delicately poke the probe from the side of the rolls into the middle to find the lowest temperature. Your rolls should reach 190˚F when they are fully baked.
Don’t leave the rolls in the pan longer than 10 minutes after they come out of the oven.
Because these rolls are so soft, you will need to leave them in the pan for just a few minutes to cool and let them “set.” However, remove them after about 10 minutes or they will become soggy.
Place them onto a paper plate, a plate covered with a paper towel or a cooling rack. After about 20 minutes, I pull the rolls apart and pile them into a basket lined with a towel.
By this time, you will have people gathered around wanting to taste-test for you. I let them! Everyone will appreciate your efforts more when they are hungry.
Frequently Asked Questions:
Can I make this dinner roll recipe ahead of time?
Yes. Go ahead and shape the rolls and put them in the pan you plan to use to bake them.
The next day, take the rolls out of the fridge 1-2 hours before you plan to bake them. Let the cold rolls come to room temperature and rise a little bit. When they are puffy, bake them in a preheated oven until golden brown.
Can I make a double batch of yeast rolls when using a bread machine?
Doubling a bread machine recipe is rarely a good idea unless you are actually mixing the dough with a stand mixer or by hand. A bread maker has a limit to how much flour it can knead properly. The size of most machines limit the recipe to around 4 cups of flour, but some are even less.
When making a double batch, there are two options.
#1 Option: If you should happen to have two machines, use them both. My second machine is old and was never good at baking bread, but it can still knead. Make one batch in each machine.
#2 Option: Make two batches in the same machine.
Assemble and start the first batch. When the kneading stops and the bread maker goes quiet after about 20 minutes, remove the dough to a large bowl. Cover it and move it to a warm place where it will continue to rise.
Clean out the bread machine pan and assemble a new batch in your bread machine. You can allow the second batch to complete the DOUGH cycle. Remove the dough and continue as usual.
If you are in a hurry, remove the dough from the second batch to another large bowl. Cover and set the bowl in a warmer place to rise. Oftentimes, my second batch will catch up to the first batch and they will both be ready to shape at almost the same time.
Change the flour and make white whole-wheat rolls. Add rosemary and brown the butter to make a wreath with the balls for a holiday meal.
Because I never quit tweaking my recipes…
I adapted this super simple recipe by adding the Tangzhong technique. In my opinion, it’s even better because the rolls are flaky and stay fresh longer. The secret is in a liquid/flour paste that allows the baker to use less flour. However, it is slightly more trouble. You can see the recipe for my Favorite Dinner Rolls with the Tangzhong method here.
How to shape bread machine dinner rolls:
I hope these pictures will give you an idea how to transform the dough into dinner rolls. There is more than one way to make a dinner roll.
Some people like to roll the balls on a floured surface. Others roll them between their hands. But I like the method shown in the video. Once you get the hang of it, it goes much faster.
My best kitchen secret for shaping…
“Don’t worry about making perfect dough balls. If they are too perfect, people will think you bought your rolls from the grocery store.”
More Bread Machine Recipes and Tips
Did you try this recipe and enjoy it? Consider helping other readers (and me) by returning to this post. Leave a rating on the recipe card itself underneath the picture. No comment required.
If you have a question or tip to share, please leave it in the regular comments after the recipe so I can answer back. Or email me: paula at saladinajar.com.
Thank you for visiting!